attune/work-summary/sessions/2024-01-13-secret-management-api.md

Work Summary: Secret Management API Implementation

Date: 2024-01-13
Session Duration: ~2 hours
Status: ✅ Complete

---

Overview

Implemented a complete, production-ready Secret Management API for the Attune automation platform. This security-critical component provides encrypted storage and retrieval of sensitive credentials, API keys, tokens, and other secret values using military-grade AES-256-GCM encryption.

---

What Was Accomplished

1. Created Encryption Module

File: crates/common/src/crypto.rs (229 lines)

Implemented comprehensive encryption utilities using AES-256-GCM:

Functions:

• encrypt() - Encrypts plaintext using AES-256-GCM with random nonces
• decrypt() - Decrypts ciphertext and validates authentication
• derive_key() - Derives 256-bit AES key from encryption key using SHA-256
• generate_nonce() - Generates random 96-bit nonces for GCM mode
• hash_encryption_key() - Hashes encryption key for verification

Security Features:

• AES-256-GCM encryption (NIST-approved, AEAD cipher)
• Random nonce generation for each encryption (prevents pattern analysis)
• SHA-256 key derivation from server encryption key
• Built-in authentication tag prevents tampering
• Base64 encoding for storage compatibility
• Comprehensive error handling

Test Coverage:

• 10 comprehensive unit tests (100% passing)
• Tests cover: roundtrip encryption, wrong key detection, validation, Unicode support, edge cases

2. Created Secret Management DTOs

File: crates/api/src/dto/key.rs (185 lines)

Key DTOs:

• KeyResponse: Full key details including decrypted value
• KeySummary: List view with redacted values (security)
• CreateKeyRequest: Create payload with validation rules
• UpdateKeyRequest: Update payload for name/value changes
• KeyQueryParams: Query parameters with filtering and pagination

Key Features:

• Automatic value redaction in list views
• Support for multiple owner types (system, identity, pack, action, sensor)
• Comprehensive validation (length limits, required fields)
• Flexible ownership model for organization

3. Implemented Secret Management Routes

File: crates/api/src/routes/keys.rs (303 lines)

Implemented 5 secure endpoints:

1. POST /api/v1/keys - Create key/secret

   • Validates input
   • Encrypts value with AES-256-GCM
   • Stores encryption key hash for verification
   • Returns decrypted value in response

2. GET /api/v1/keys - List keys (values redacted)

   • Filter by owner type or owner string
   • Pagination support
   • Never exposes secret values in list view
   • Returns summary objects only

3. GET /api/v1/keys/:ref - Get key value

   • Retrieves single key by reference
   • Automatically decrypts encrypted values
   • Returns plaintext value in response
   • Handles decryption errors gracefully

4. PUT /api/v1/keys/:ref - Update key value

   • Updates name and/or value
   • Re-encrypts value if encryption enabled
   • Handles encryption status changes
   • Returns decrypted value in response

5. DELETE /api/v1/keys/:ref - Delete key

   • Permanently removes key from database
   • Verifies key exists before deletion

Security Measures:

• JWT authentication required on all endpoints
• Encryption key accessed from server config
• Detailed error logging (without exposing secrets)
• Graceful error handling for decryption failures
• Value redaction in list responses

4. Enhanced Application State

Modified: crates/api/src/state.rs

• Added config: Arc<Config> to AppState
• Enables routes to access encryption key
• Updated AppState constructor

Modified: crates/api/src/main.rs

• Pass config to AppState during initialization
• Maintains backward compatibility

5. Added Cryptography Dependencies

Modified: Cargo.toml (workspace)

Added dependencies:

• aes-gcm = "0.10" - AES-256-GCM encryption
• sha2 = "0.10" - SHA-256 hashing

Modified: crates/common/Cargo.toml

• Added aes-gcm and sha2 to dependencies
• Added crypto module to lib.rs exports

6. Registered Routes

Modified Files:

• crates/api/src/routes/mod.rs - Added keys module export
• crates/api/src/server.rs - Registered key routes in API router
• crates/api/src/dto/mod.rs - Exported key DTOs

7. Created Comprehensive API Documentation

File: docs/api-secrets.md (772 lines)

Complete documentation including:

• Security model and encryption details
• Key model specification with all fields
• Owner type descriptions and use cases
• Detailed endpoint documentation with:
  • Request/response examples
  • Query parameters
  • Field validation rules
  • Error responses
  • Security notes
• Use case examples:
  • Storing API credentials
  • Storing database passwords
  • Storing OAuth tokens
  • Retrieving secrets for actions
  • Updating expired tokens
• Security best practices:
  • Always encrypt sensitive data
  • Use descriptive references
  • Associate with owners
  • Rotate secrets regularly
  • Never log secret values
  • Limit access
  • Backup encryption key
  • Use environment-specific secrets
• Encryption algorithm details
• Error handling reference
• Future enhancement roadmap

8. Updated Project Documentation

File: work-summary/TODO.md

• Marked Secret Management API (section 2.10) as ✅ COMPLETE
• Listed all 5 implemented endpoints
• Noted encryption implementation

File: CHANGELOG.md

• Added Phase 2.10 entry with complete feature list
• Documented security features
• Listed dependencies added

---

Technical Details

Encryption Implementation

Algorithm: AES-256-GCM (Galois/Counter Mode)

Process:

1. Server encryption key (from config) is hashed with SHA-256 → 256-bit AES key
2. Random 96-bit nonce is generated using cryptographically secure RNG
3. Plaintext is encrypted using AES-256-GCM with key and nonce
4. Result: nonce || ciphertext || authentication_tag
5. Base64 encode for storage in database

Security Properties:

• Confidentiality: AES-256 prevents unauthorized reading
• Authenticity: GCM authentication tag prevents tampering
• Non-deterministic: Random nonces ensure unique ciphertexts
• Forward Security: Key rotation possible (requires re-encryption)

Key Storage Model

keys table:
  - id: Unique identifier
  - ref: Unique reference (e.g., "github_token")
  - owner_type: system/identity/pack/action/sensor
  - owner_*: Various owner reference fields
  - name: Human-readable name
  - encrypted: Boolean flag
  - encryption_key_hash: SHA-256 hash of encryption key
  - value: Encrypted (base64) or plaintext value
  - created/updated: Timestamps

API Security Features

1. Value Redaction: List endpoints never expose values
2. Automatic Encryption: Values encrypted on create/update
3. Automatic Decryption: Values decrypted on retrieval
4. Key Validation: Encryption key must be ≥32 characters
5. Error Handling: Graceful handling of decryption failures
6. Audit Trail: Creation and modification timestamps

Code Quality

• ✅ Follows established patterns from other route modules
• ✅ Comprehensive error handling with descriptive messages
• ✅ Input validation using validator crate
• ✅ Type-safe with proper Rust idioms
• ✅ Clean separation of concerns (crypto, DTOs, routes)
• ✅ Extensive inline documentation
• ✅ Zero compile errors
• ✅ 10/10 crypto tests passing

Testing Status

• ✅ Compiles successfully with no errors
• ✅ All crypto unit tests passing (10/10)
• ✅ Encryption/decryption roundtrip verified
• ✅ Wrong key detection tested
• ✅ Unicode support tested
• ⚠️ Only compiler warnings (unused imports - not related)
• ❌ No API integration tests yet (noted for future work)

---

Use Cases Enabled

1. Store API Credentials

Store third-party API keys for use in actions:

POST /api/v1/keys
{
  "ref": "github_api_token",
  "owner_type": "pack",
  "owner_pack_ref": "github",
  "name": "GitHub Personal Access Token",
  "value": "ghp_abc123...",
  "encrypted": true
}

2. Store Database Credentials

Store database passwords securely:

POST /api/v1/keys
{
  "ref": "prod_db_password",
  "owner_type": "system",
  "name": "Production Database Password",
  "value": "supersecret123!",
  "encrypted": true
}

3. Retrieve Secrets in Actions

Actions can retrieve secrets at runtime:

GET /api/v1/keys/github_api_token
# Returns decrypted value for use

4. Rotate Expired Credentials

Update secrets when credentials change:

PUT /api/v1/keys/github_api_token
{
  "value": "ghp_newtoken_after_rotation"
}
# Automatically re-encrypts

---

Security Considerations

What We Did Right

1. Encryption by Default: encrypted: true is the default
2. Value Redaction: List views never expose values
3. Strong Encryption: AES-256-GCM is NIST-approved
4. Random Nonces: Prevents pattern analysis
5. Authentication: GCM mode prevents tampering
6. Key Derivation: SHA-256 hashing of server key
7. Error Handling: No secret exposure in errors
8. Documentation: Comprehensive security best practices

Important Warnings

⚠️ Encryption Key Management:

• Key must be at least 32 characters
• Key must be kept secret and secure
• Key must be backed up securely
• Losing the key means encrypted secrets cannot be recovered
• Key rotation requires re-encrypting all secrets

⚠️ Production Deployment:

• Always use HTTPS to protect secrets in transit
• Never commit encryption key to version control
• Use environment variables or secret management for key
• Implement key rotation policy
• Monitor and audit secret access (future enhancement)

---

Issues Encountered & Resolved

1. AppState Missing Config

Problem: Routes needed access to encryption key from config, but AppState only had database pool and JWT config

Solution: Added config: Arc<Config> to AppState and updated constructor in main.rs

2. Encryption Dependencies

Problem: No AES-GCM or SHA-2 libraries available

Solution: Added aes-gcm and sha2 to workspace and crate dependencies

3. Value Redaction Strategy

Problem: Need to prevent value exposure in list views while allowing retrieval

Solution:

• Created separate KeySummary DTO without value field
• List endpoint returns summaries
• Individual GET endpoint returns full KeyResponse with decrypted value

---

Dependencies Added

• aes-gcm 0.10: AES-256-GCM authenticated encryption
• sha2 0.10: SHA-256 hashing for key derivation
• base64 (already present): Base64 encoding for storage

---

Next Steps

Immediate (Complete Phase 2)

1. API Documentation (Phase 2.11)

   • Add OpenAPI/Swagger annotations
   • Generate interactive API docs
   • Serve docs at /docs endpoint

2. API Testing (Phase 2.12)

   • Write integration tests for secret endpoints
   • Test encryption/decryption flow
   • Test value redaction
   • Test access control

Future Enhancements (Security)

1. Key Rotation: Implement re-encryption when changing keys
2. Access Control Lists: Fine-grained permissions on secrets
3. Audit Logging: Detailed logs of all secret access
4. Secret Expiration: Time-to-live (TTL) for temporary secrets
5. Secret Versioning: Keep history of value changes
6. Vault Integration: Support HashiCorp Vault, AWS Secrets Manager
7. Secret References: Reference secrets from other secrets
8. Import/Export: Secure bulk operations with encryption

Move to Phase 4 (After Phase 2 Complete)

4. Executor Service
   • Event consumption from RabbitMQ
   • Rule evaluation engine
   • Enforcement creation
   • Execution scheduling
   • Use secrets from Key API

---

Files Created/Modified

Created

• crates/common/src/crypto.rs (229 lines) - Encryption utilities
• crates/api/src/dto/key.rs (185 lines) - Key DTOs
• crates/api/src/routes/keys.rs (303 lines) - Secret management routes
• docs/api-secrets.md (772 lines) - API documentation
• work-summary/2024-01-13-secret-management-api.md (this file)

Modified

• Cargo.toml - Added aes-gcm and sha2 dependencies
• crates/common/Cargo.toml - Added crypto dependencies
• crates/common/src/lib.rs - Added crypto module export
• crates/api/src/state.rs - Added config to AppState
• crates/api/src/main.rs - Pass config to AppState
• crates/api/src/dto/mod.rs - Added key exports
• crates/api/src/routes/mod.rs - Added keys module
• crates/api/src/server.rs - Registered key routes
• work-summary/TODO.md - Marked Phase 2.10 complete
• CHANGELOG.md - Added Phase 2.10 entry

Total Lines Added: ~1,489 lines (code + documentation)

---

Configuration Required

Server Configuration

Add to config.yaml or environment variables:

security:
  encryption_key: "your-encryption-key-must-be-at-least-32-characters-long"

Or:

export ATTUNE__SECURITY__ENCRYPTION_KEY="your-encryption-key-must-be-at-least-32-characters-long"

Requirements:

• Minimum 32 characters
• Keep secret and secure
• Back up securely
• Never commit to version control

---

Conclusion

Successfully implemented a complete, production-ready Secret Management API with military-grade encryption for the Attune platform. The implementation provides secure storage and retrieval of sensitive credentials while following security best practices.

The secret management system now supports:

• ✅ AES-256-GCM encrypted storage
• ✅ Automatic encryption/decryption
• ✅ Value redaction in list views
• ✅ Multiple ownership models
• ✅ Flexible organization
• ✅ Comprehensive documentation
• ✅ Security best practices guide

Phase 2.10 (Secret Management API) is now complete! 🎉

This completes all major CRUD APIs for Phase 2. The API Service now has:

• ✅ Authentication & Authorization
• ✅ Pack Management
• ✅ Action Management
• ✅ Trigger & Sensor Management
• ✅ Rule Management
• ✅ Execution Queries
• ✅ Inquiry Management (Human-in-the-Loop)
• ✅ Event & Enforcement Queries
• ✅ Secret Management (Encrypted Credentials)

Next: API Documentation (OpenAPI/Swagger) and Testing, then move to Phase 4 (Executor Service) to make the automation actually run!

---

Verification Commands

# Build API service
cargo build -p attune-api

# Check for errors
cargo check -p attune-api

# Run crypto tests
cargo test -p attune-common --lib crypto

# Run all tests (when implemented)
cargo test -p attune-api

# Run clippy for linting
cargo clippy -p attune-api

Testing the API

# Set encryption key
export ATTUNE__SECURITY__ENCRYPTION_KEY="test-encryption-key-32-chars-min"

# Start API server
cargo run -p attune-api

# Create a secret
curl -X POST "http://localhost:8080/api/v1/keys" \
  -H "Authorization: Bearer <token>" \
  -H "Content-Type: application/json" \
  -d '{
    "ref": "test_secret",
    "owner_type": "system",
    "name": "Test Secret",
    "value": "my_secret_password",
    "encrypted": true
  }'

# List secrets (values redacted)
curl -X GET "http://localhost:8080/api/v1/keys" \
  -H "Authorization: Bearer <token>"

# Get secret value (decrypted)
curl -X GET "http://localhost:8080/api/v1/keys/test_secret" \
  -H "Authorization: Bearer <token>"